Is Patriotism A Virtue?

The word "patriot" has as part of it's root the Latin word for "Father". Think of the prayer "Pater Nostra" for example. It's a bit of an older way of speaking, but we sometimes call our home country the "Fatherland". So someone who is a patriot is someone who has a love for their fatherland, or their home country. Patriotism describes one's love for their fatherland. When it comes to love of America, there is something in the culture which causes some people to pause or hesitate. Should we love America? 

Sometimes you see this in the current culture war surrounding the phrase "Make America Great Again". I often hear a leftist ask, "When was America ever great?" So, if I were to tell my leftist friends I was proud to be an American, or I love that I am an American, they may ask, "What is there to be proud of?" with their noses raised. 

There is plenty to be proud of. I can worship the Lord every Sunday without any considerable fear of being murdered for it. I can't say that of other countries. And that's a pretty big deal, being high up there in the hierarchy of the good life. But suppose I weren't so quick on my feet and couldn't think of any particular cause for my being proud to be an American. Would that then fail to justify my patriotism? No, it would not. I could have patriotism for my country even if I had nothing to point to. 

To see why, consider your own parents. Surely you love them. But why? Sure, you could say, "Because they fed me, raised me, nurtured me, etc." but then suppose that they hadn't done that. Could you still love them? It seems reasonable to say yes. I loved my son before he was born. I loved him from the moment he was conceived in his mothers womb. He did absolutely nothing for me. I had done absolutely nothing for him yet. There is nothing I can point to that we did that would justify our love for each other. Yet there it is. 

The reason the love exists is in virtue of the relationship we have with each other. The relation is that of Father-Son. I love him not because of anything he did, but in virtue of just being my son. And he loves me, not because I tickle him or throw him up in the air, or because I make sure he isn't choking on his food, but simply in virtue of me being his dad. And that's enough. Just being in that relation is cause enough for our love. 

So, take this principle and apply to patriotism. Can we say we love our country, even if there was nothing to point at? Yeah, it seems so. Can we love our country even if it's done horrible things? Yeah, my parents are sinners, I still love them. I am a wretched human and try not to let it affect my dadhood, but it does, and my boy still loves me. God still loves His own sinful children. So too then is it true of America and it's citizens, in virtue of that relationship. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Milo

Image
So I decided to go see Milo Yiannopoulos at UCSB yesterday. I was really hesitant to do so, and decided not to go, but a few of my friends wanted to go, and they're all losers who don't drive, so, I had to take everyone. I didn't know much about Milo, and I still don't, but I did learn some things. In some of the more, ahem, colorfully conservative pages of facebook that I follow, Milo has been something of an iconoclast, destroying the feminist narratives left and right. But I also know that he is an active homosexual and he is a rabid Trump supporter (even calling him "Daddy"). So, for those reasons, I was never interested in what he had to say. He was, to take a phrase from Lenin, a useful idiot. That was my impression. But I was wrong. A few days before the event, I had read somewhere on these pages I follow but wont name, that Milo believed himself to be a Christian, and a Catholic at that. I dismissed this immediately, and my opinion of him stoppe...
Read more

What Does The Bible Say About Birth Control?

From the early church up to 1930, virtually every church believed contraception was a sin. That fact alone should have us induce that contraception is in fact a sin. Yet, there are many Christians today, even in my own congregation, that will never entertain the possibility of contraception being a sin.
Read more

Is Canon 28 Binding?

In my previous post , I discussed Canon 28 of the Council of Chalcedon (you'll find the full text of the canon there). But I should have put an asterisk on the conversation because Canon 28 isn't properly part of the council. You'll remember from an earlier post , that what makes a council ecumenical is ratification from the Roman Pontiff. Canons are part of councils. And naturally, canons also have to be ratified. However, Canon 28 was not ratified by Pope Leo (Roman Pontiff at the time). So Canon 28 isn't part of the council and thus isn't binding.  If you are Orthodox, this may sound too convenient. I've already suggested why Roman Ratification is the correct theory in the previous link. However, I want to add two things. First, even Saints in the East agree with the Roman position, and second, a case can be made for Canon 28 not being problematic for Catholicism.  First, there are the sayings of Pope St. Gelasius (about 490 AD), and Pope St. Gelasius is...
Read more